I definitely would. >_>
As for mixed reviews, I think most of the mixing was due to some finding it to be too difficult, as well as some that found the old-school influences to be too copycat or not as great as their sources. Personally, I loved it, even when I was cussing it to hell.
If you've read the body of those reviews, you just need to look at the cons in the lower-scoring ones and the pros in the higher-scoring ones and ask yourself if the former would be enough to turn you off the game and if the latter is enough to get you to want to play it. Weigh those two against each other from there. But as Olethros mentioned, factoring in the sub-$20 price you can find it for might help overlook any on those cons.
Last edited by lol, forums; 09-14-2011 at 03:19 PM.